Home / Market Analysis / Asset Insights / Commodities View / The Nickel Squeeze: When Policy Twists Metal Markets and Chokes Currencies

The Nickel Squeeze: When Policy Twists Metal Markets and Chokes Currencies

Dupoin
Nickel export ban impacting rupiah
Indonesia's Ban inverts futures curves

Indonesia Doubles Down on resource nationalism

Picture Indonesia as a poker player going all-in with its nickel chips—only this game involves global supply chains and currency tremors. Fresh off its WTO loss over the 2020 nickel ore export ban, Jakarta launched "Export Ban 2.0": a sophisticated policy cocktail mixing export restrictions, royalty hikes, and capital controls. The crown jewel? The April 2025 royalty reform (PP No.18 and PP No.19) slapping nickel products with new fees—including a surprise 1.5% tax on nickel metal itself. Why? Because simply banning exports was too last season. Now they're playing multidimensional chess: forcing miners to park 100% of export earnings in local banks for a year (trapping $800M+ in liquidity), while tweaking domestic nickel pricing formulas twice monthly to "align with market reality" (read: control it). It's like watching a chef simultaneously throttle ingredients and redesign the menu—while the kitchen burns.

The Stainless Steel Curve Flip

Here's where things get spicy. Normally, stainless steel futures curve upward—you pay more for longer-dated deliveries. But since March 2025, the curve inverted like a rollercoaster loop: contracts for 3-month delivery now trade at a $50/ton premium to 12-month ones. Why? Two forces colliding:

Traders call this the "scissors effect": rising costs meet falling prices, with futures markets screaming "pain ahead!" The irony? Indonesia created its own monster by flooding the market with subsidized nickel—now it's getting mauled by the jaws of its policy.

IDR's Vicious Feedback Loop

Enter the Indonesian rupiah (IDR)—stage left, sweating. See, inverted futures curves aren't just trader drama; they're currency kryptonite. Here’s the domino chain:

It’s a self-reinforcing nightmare. Case in point: When Tsingshan postponed its Sulawesi plant in May, IDR slid 2% in 48 hours—not because fundamentals changed, but because the curve inversion deepened. Jakarta’s forex controls worsened things: forcing exporters to park dollars locally should support IDR, but instead scared off 62% of miners who shifted operations to Vietnam/Malaysia. Talk about policy backfire!

Impact of Indonesian Rupiah and Policy on Mining and Currency Dynamics
Aspect Description Indicator Effect Timing Comments
Indonesian Rupiah (IDR) Movement IDR depreciated 2% in 48 hours after Tsingshan postponed Sulawesi plant Currency Exchange Rate (IDR/USD) Sharp depreciation linked to futures curve inversion Short-term (48 hours) Not due to fundamental changes but market perception
Futures Curve Inversion Inverted futures curve causing self-reinforcing negative effects on currency Futures Curve Shape Exacerbates IDR depreciation Immediate to short-term Acts as currency kryptonite
Jakarta Forex Controls Policy forcing exporters to keep USD locally Forex Regulation / Policy Intended to support IDR but scared off 62% of miners Ongoing policy impact Backfired by pushing mining operations abroad
Mining Operations Shift Miners relocating to Vietnam and Malaysia due to policy environment Mining Industry Location 62% of miners shifted operations Following policy implementation Negative impact on Indonesia's mining sector

The Smelter Squeeze Play

Caught in this crossfire? Indonesia’s nickel smelters. They’re getting triple-pinched:

No wonder RKEF furnace utilization rates dropped to 68% last month—the lowest since 2021. One Chinese smelter manager near Morowali put it darkly: "We’re mining rupiahs now, not nickel." Translation? They’re losing money on every ton but praying currency depreciation saves them. That’s not business—it’s desperation bingo.

Breaking the Cycle (Or Not)

Can Jakarta stop this doom loop? Unlikely soon. Their "solutions" so far:

The real exit? Either swallow pride and moderate policies—or pray the Philippines’ June nickel ban lifts global prices enough to offset their self-sabotage. But with LME warehouses stuffed with 200K tons of spare nickel, hope is thinner than a smelter’s profit margin.

Beyond Nickel: The New Emerging Market Playbook

Indonesia’s spiral offers a masterclass for commodity-driven economies: resource nationalism in the 2020s requires surgical precision, not sledgehammers. When you choke exports while flooding markets, you breed futures curve inversions that become currency killers. And capital controls? They’re like tourniquets—useful briefly but deadly if left on too long. As Vietnam and Malaysia lure away $30B in diverted nickel investment, the lesson screams: In global trade, you can’t bully markets without bleeding money. Jakarta’s gamble might yet pay off if battery demand saves nickel—but for now, stainless steel traders are voting with their contracts. And their verdict is written in inverted curves and falling rupiahs.

What is Indonesia's "Export Ban 2.0" policy?

Indonesia's latest nickel policy cocktail includes:

  • New royalty fees on nickel products (PP No.18 & PP No.19)
  • A surprise 1.5% tax on nickel metal itself
  • Requiring miners to park 100% of export earnings locally for 1 year
  • Biweekly adjustments to domestic nickel pricing formulas
"It's like watching a chef simultaneously throttle ingredients and redesign the menu—while the kitchen burns"
This traps over $800M in liquidity while giving Jakarta unprecedented market control.
What's causing the stainless steel futures curve inversion?

The "scissors effect" has inverted the curve with:

  1. Rising costs from Indonesian policies (new taxes + power subsidies)
  2. Falling prices from global oversupply
Result: 3-month contracts now trade at to 12-month ones - a market scream of "pain ahead!"
How is this impacting the Indonesian rupiah (IDR)?

A vicious feedback loop is crushing IDR:

  • Inverted curves → Investor panic → Capital flight
  • Policy uncertainty → Smelter shutdowns → Less dollar inflow
  • Forex controls → Miner exodus to Vietnam/Malaysia
"When Tsingshan postponed its Sulawesi plant, IDR slid 2% in 48 hours—not because fundamentals changed, but because the curve inversion deepened"
What's the triple-pinch hitting nickel smelters?

Smelters are caught in a perfect storm:

  1. Input cost surge: Royalty hikes + ore quality taxes
  2. Output price crash: Global oversupply
  3. Currency chaos: IDR volatility
Result: RKEF furnace utilization at 68% - lowest since 2021. One manager grimly noted:
Can Jakarta break this doom loop?

Current solutions are backfiring:

  • Price floors: Easily bypassed via transfer pricing
  • Export tax breaks: Too small to offset costs
  • State stockpiling: Insufficient funding
The real exit? Either
"swallow pride and moderate policies"
or hope Philippines' nickel ban lifts global prices. But with LME warehouses stuffed with 200K tons, hope is thin.
What's the lesson for emerging markets?

Indonesia offers a cautionary masterclass:

  1. Resource nationalism requires surgical precision, not sledgehammers
  2. Choking exports while flooding markets breeds curve inversions
  3. Capital controls are "like tourniquets—useful briefly but deadly if left on too long"
With $30B in nickel investment diverted to Vietnam/Malaysia, the verdict is clear:
"You can’t bully markets without bleeding money"